Tesla's autopilot defect is well known to its CEO Elon Musk, Says the Judge
- Tesla faces trial over allegations that its Autopilot system is defective.
- The family of a man who died in a crash while using Autopilot is seeking punitive damages.
- The judge found that Tesla knew of Autopilot's defects but allowed cars to be driven in unsafe areas.
Tesla Faces Trial in Florida Over Autopilot Defects
For the first time, a Florida judge found out last week that both Tesla and its top officials, which include CEO Elon Musk, can be sued for product liability on alleged defects in its autopilot system. The judge found "reasonable evidence" that Tesla was aware of the defects yet allowed its cars to operate in areas deemed "not safe for that technology." The family of a man who died in a 2019 crash while using Autopilot is seeking punitive damages for intentional misconduct and gross negligence.
Case Background and Delay: The lawsuit stems from a 2019 crash in Miami, where Stephen Banner's Model 3 collided with a turning 18-wheeler, resulting in his death. The trial, initially set for October, has been delayed.
Potential Testimony and Marketing Strategy: Judge Reid Scott's findings may require Elon Musk to testify. The judge highlighted Tesla's marketing, portraying products as autonomous, and Musk's public statements influencing beliefs about product capabilities.
Autopilot Engineer Testimony: Autopilot engineer Adam Gustafsson testified that Autopilot failed to detect the semitrailer in Banners and a similar 2016 crash involving Joshua Brown. Despite awareness, no changes were made to the system, indicating potential negligence.
Tesla's Likely Defense and NTSB Investigation: Tesla may argue human error, as in previous cases. An NTSB investigation found shared blame but noted Autopilot's failure to warn the driver.
Legal Precedent: Tesla's legal strategy may rely on past victories, including a California jury's decision in April that Tesla was not to blame for a 2019 Autopilot crash. Another recent jury sided with Tesla over allegations linking Autopilot to a driver's death in 2019.
The trial's outcome could impact the future of autonomous driving technology and hold implications for manufacturers' accountability in addressing system defects.